Sunday, 17th December 2017

‘Almost’ Pakistan: G-B in a constitutional limbo

map_gilgit.gif

For the people of Gilgit-Baltistan (GB), there are two independence days every year: August 14, with the rest of Pakistan; and November 1, when they first found freedom. There is permanent confusion in GB, brought about by keeping the territory and its populace in a constitutional limbo regarding their status in the federation: is GB part of Pakistan or is it just a disputed territory?

G-B’s modern history can be traced back to the 19th century. In 1846, after many wars and much bloodshed, GB was incorporated in the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir by the Dogras. GB comprised several independent princely states, and all of them now started paying revenue and taxes to the Dogra Raj. The Dogras had an army for the region too, called the Gilgit Scouts.

The Dogra Raj continued for a century, but 1947 spelled upheaval in South Asia and GB was not spared either. With two sovereign states being carved out of united India, GB found itself neither part of India nor part of Pakistan. Even though the Dogras still maintained control over GB after August 1947, their influence was on the wane.

The Dogras were dealt a final blow when a local commander of the Gilgit Scouts, a man named Colonel Mirza Hassan Khan, led a successful rebellion against the Dogra Raj. A government was formed thereafter, for the new Republic of Gilgit, whose president was Shah Raees Khan. Colonel Khan meanwhile became the chief of the Gilgit Scouts.

The new republic could only maintain itself for 16 days. Mohammad Ali Jinnah, the leader of Pakistan, was then approached and requested permission for Gilgit to join the Pakistan federation. This was an unconditional offer, which was duly accepted by Jinnah. Pakistan sent a political agent to Gilgit Agency, a man named Sardar Alam Khan, while the Frontier Crimes Regulation (FCR) was imposed as the law of the land. Even though the princely states stayed intact, Pakistan had taken over administrative control of Gilgit.

But while the people of Gilgit expected this accession to mean they were now citizens of Pakistan, this wasn’t entirely the case.

Ever since its accession to Pakistan, Gilgit’s fortunes became intertwined with those of Kashmir, even though the matters differed qualitatively. Gilgit’s was a straightforward case, having joined the Pakistani federation of its accord and without any conditions. Kashmir, meanwhile, was at the centre of a controversy over which country it was actually a part of, and whether Azad Kashmir was a legitimate territorial entity.

As the matter of Kashmir went to the United Nations in 1948 for resolution, so did the matter of Gilgit.

It was claimed by Pakistani authorities at the time that Gilgit, like Kashmir, was a disputed territory. Since both India and Pakistan were asking for a UN-conducted plebiscite in disputed areas, their calculation was that Gilgit’s people would vote in support of Pakistan and thus, swell the vote in favour of Pakistan. In one move, therefore, Kashmir and Gilgit would officially be part of Pakistan.

The UN advised both India and Pakistan to remove their armies from all disputed territories, so that a UN-supervised referendum could take place. Neither country was prepared to let go of territories under their control, and the matter went into cold storage.

On April 28, 1949, officials of Pakistan government met with those of Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) government to ink the Karachi Agreement. Under this accord, it was agreed that the affairs of Gilgit would now be run by the government of Pakistan rather than the AJK government. A separate ministry was created by the Pakistan government too; the federal ministry of Kashmir Affairs and Northern Areas was to run Gilgit and adjoining areas. No leader from Gilgit was included in this agreement, and a handover of power took place without the consent of the people of Gilgit.

Matters continued in the same vein till 1970, when a single administrative unit was carved out of Gilgit Agency, the Baltistan region, and the former princely states of Hunza and Nagar.

In 1972, Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto visited the area and promptly announced the abolition of all princely states. A representative body was formed, named the Northern Areas Advisory Council. This was an 18-member body that was chosen through direct elections and was to be headed by a commissioner.

When General Ziaul Haq assumed power, he promised representation for the Northern Areas in his Majlis-i-Shoora. But all talk came to naught, as only two members could be sent to the Shoora from the Northern Areas, and that too as observers / ex-officio members.

In 1988, Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto again made changes to the laws governing the Northern Areas. A new body, called the Northern Areas Council, was duly formed. In her second tenure, Benazir introduced the Legal Framework Order (LFO)-1994, which turned the Northern Areas Council into the Northern Areas Legislative Council. The leader of the house of this body was the deputy chief executive, while the minister of Kashmir Affairs and Northern Areas served as chief executive.

The Northern Areas Legislative Council only had limited legislative powers. Even though it was handed 49 subjects, all of these were local governance decisions: local taxes, irrigation, out-of-court settlements, among others. More substantive powers arrived, ironically, with a dictator.

In 1999, as General Pervez Musharraf was settling in, the Northern Areas were seeing yet another legislative assembly complete its term. In fact, irrespective of political developments in mainland Pakistan, democratic processes remained intact in the Northern Areas. Another set of elections took place in 2004, after which Gen Musharraf visited the region in 2006.

As part of his changes, the General made sweeping changes to the LFO. Greater fiscal responsibility was handed to the Northern Areas government and a new post of principal accounting officer was created. The Northern Areas Legislative Council turned into the Northern Areas Legislative Assembly, with the number of subjects it exercised control over increased to 61. The leader of the house was now the chief executive, while the minister of Kashmir Affairs and Northern Areas became the chairman of the legislative assembly.

The most significant change made by Gen Musharraf was granting the Northern Areas Legislative Assembly the right to amend the LFO. In an irony of sorts, the new democratic government of Yousuf Raza Gilani withdrew these powers when they unveiled their package for the Northern Areas.

In fact, Gilani’s government — in an attempt to prop support for their party — sought to bring about wide-ranging political reforms. The rationale was that in order to win a mandate in the Northern Areas, these reforms needed to be instituted before the 2013 elections. This package was named the “Gilgit-Baltistan Empowerment and Self-Government Order (GBESGO)-2009”. It came directly as a presidential order rather than an act of parliament.

Unveiling the reforms package on September 8, 2009, Prime Minister Gilani did away with the term “Northern Areas” and replaced it with “Gilgit-Baltistan.” This was a long-standing demand of the people, since northern areas merely denotes a direction rather than describe a people or their land. Moreover, the region’s tourist economy was being shrunk due to its location being confused with terror-infested Fata. A change of name thus served to rebuild the image of the region too.

Under the new law, the chief executive was now the chief minister, while there was also provision for a federally-appointed governor. Advisors in the legislative assembly were now ministers.

The GB Council was now comprised 15 members, six of whom were elected from the GB Legislative Assembly while the rest were elected members from Pakistani assemblies. The prime minister was the council chairman, while the minister of Kashmir Affairs was the deputy chairman. Meetings of this body were to be mostly held in Islamabad. The GB Council was to serve as the upper house of parliament; legislation pertaining to tourism, minerals, forests, as well as water and power all rested with the Council.

Despite these changes, reservations remained among the local GB populace over what they perceived to be a skewed balance of power. Not only was the right to amend the LFO taken away from them, for example, but the Council was handed greater powers than the GB Legislative Assembly and most important decisions were to be made by them. But this body was dominated by federal representatives rather than local ones, many of their agendas were not to benefit the local populace but to maintain their control over governance.

The central issue for the populace of Gilgit-Baltistan remained the same: is their area officially part of Pakistan and are they now legitimate Pakistani citizens?

In unveiling the new laws, PM Gilani had used the word “autonomy” for GB, but in truth, GB is still a disputed territory. Even as the Gilani-government started discussions to frame the new law, the advice they sought was from the ministry of Kashmir Affairs and Northern Areas, rather than local GB representatives.

For the people of GB, it was clear that the ministry of Kashmir Affairs and Northern Areas would not provide any advice that would compromise its hold over power in GB. The ministry has been used directly or indirectly to curtail people’s rights in GB; the status quo did not change despite Gilani’s new laws. GB still cannot claim a share in the National Finance Commission (NFC) Award, for example.

Then there is the question of whether GB laws are applicable in Pakistani courts. Last year, an anti-terrorism court in GB sentenced a media mogul to 26 years in prison in a case pertaining to blasphemy. But the decision could not be implemented because GB law had no jurisdiction in Pakistan.

Amidst such confusions, peaks such as K-2 or heroes such as Lalik Jan Shaheed (Nishan-i-Haider) are claimed as Pakistani even though they are from GB. Local wisdom dictates that when it suits Pakistan, GB is a formal part of the country; and when it suits Pakistan to show GB as a disputed territory, it is shown as that.

This year too, the people of GB will once again celebrate two independence days — one for their homeland and the other for a country that refuses to fully accept them. --  DAWN

Comments  

 
0 # Shehbaz Khan 2015-08-10 09:48
I agree with each and every point of this article except a misunderstandin g of the author about the terming of the GB (Empowerment & Self Governance) Order 2009 as a PRESIDENTIAL ORDER.. Not at all sir, this is an Executive Order of Ministry of Kashmir & GB Islamabad promulgated under the S.R.O No. 786 (1) 2009 on 09/09/2009. A unique kind of governing document on the globe which is neither a "law" nor a "constitution" rather a remote controlled colonial instrument to govern GB by the federal bureaucracy from the corridors in Islamabad.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Opinions

11/12/2017, 14:03 OUTPOST
centenary-celebration-suspension-bride-gilgit-river   Dr. Abdul Jalil Built in 1905 during British Raj, spanning 560 feet, Suspension Bridge Gilgit River is always spick and span since its...
19/11/2017, 01:28 OUTPOST
biodiversity-conservation-in-gilgit-baltistan-2 By Manzoor Ahmed Qureshi  Pakistan being signatory to Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and many other multilateral agreement and accords...
31/10/2017, 12:27 OUTPOST
economic-dimensions-of-cpec-2 Dr Abdul Jalil   It is widely believed or made to believe that CPEC will be a harbinger of prosperity, a game changer that will dynamise the...
27/03/2017, 18:36 OUTPOST
by-choice-pakistanis By Musa Ali Khan People in Gilgit-Baltistan (G-B) love Pakistan with national pride. This culture of chauvinism dates back to November 1, 1948 when...
25/12/2016, 22:57 OUTPOST
2016-12-25-17-57-02 تحریر : شبیر میر  بات نکلی ہے کرپشن کی ۔ ایک زمانے میں کہا جاتا تھا کہ اگر اپ ایک پرسکون زندگی گزارنا چاہتے ہیں تو کرپشن سے دور رہیں۔ سزا، معاشرے...
24/12/2016, 13:07 OUTPOST
poverty-frustration-and-youthBy Musa Ali Khan The government of Gilgit-Baltistan allocates PKR 70 million for every member of G-B Legislative Assembly for rural development such as...
11/12/2016, 20:41 OUTPOST
pakistan-us-china-and-cpec    By Fahad Rasheed Throughout the history, Pakistan has managed to cultivate good relations with United States and China, thanks mainly to...
27/11/2016, 22:06 OUTPOST
what-i-learned-about-joint-family-system-in-us By Raja Mushtaq Ahmad  As I talked about my stay in Oregon previously in these pages, there exist some basic differences between Gilgit-Baltistan...
19/11/2016, 10:36 OUTPOST
from-eugene-to-gilgit-baltistan    BY RAJA MUSHTAQ AHMAD  I work as a faculty member at Karakoram International University (KIU). Currently, for one semester I am in...
29/09/2016, 12:34 OUTPOST
indian-interest-in-gilgit    BY SHABBIR MIR As the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) progresses, India has placed more focus on Gilgit-Baltistan in an attempt...
25/09/2016, 12:20 OUTPOST
beautification-of-rawalpindi-city-through-heritage-development Buildings, like people, have stories to tell about their community and the nation’s past. Embedded in historic structures and landscapes are traces of...
09/08/2016, 00:54 OUTPOST
upcoming-reforms-in-education BY KULSOOM ZAHRA “Education is a movement from darkness to light” (Allan Bloom) I find an abundance of truth in this statement, because it is...
13/06/2016, 13:33 OUTPOST
call-for-educational-emergency-in-diamer BY FIDA KARIM Lately Alif Ailaan and ASER Pakistan have released their reports on Pakistan District Education Rankings 2016  and Annual Status of...
04/05/2016, 00:09 OUTPOST
exchange-program-a-tool-for-development BY SHIGRI JUNIOR SKARDU: I feel that youth exchange program such as those organized by the National Youth Assembly (NYA) for its members are...
10/03/2016, 20:28 OUTPOST
gilgit-baltistan-unique-history-complicated-present  BY EJAZ KARIM Gilgit-Baltistan has a unique history, a complicated present and an ambiguous future. It has been known by several names due to its...
15/01/2016, 12:02 OUTPOST
g-b-and-onstitutional-dilemma DR WAJAHAT A DAR It was on the headlines a few weeks back that federal government is mulling options to merge Gilgit-Baltistan constitutionally as...
12/01/2016, 17:28 OUTPOST
g-b-isn-t-your-issue   BY M.A MIR The people of Gilgit-Baltistan [G-B] want to join federation of Pakistan. I am wondering why the people back in Muzaffarabad,...
09/01/2016, 23:20 OUTPOST
snow-in-skardu-and-flights  BY SHABBIR MIR A large portion of the valley in Gilgit-Baltistan has received considerable snowfall of late. Apart from the mountains, the snow...
09/01/2016, 01:50 OUTPOST
gilgit-baltistan-part-of-pakistan-by-choiceBY YAQOOB KHAN BANGASH Over the last couple of days, news has surfaced that the government might be mulling a change in the constitutional status of...
20/12/2015, 10:31 OUTPOST
pakistan-s-evolving-foreign-policy-on-terrorism   BY WAJAHAT A. DAR Foreign office first termed it as a "shocking surprise". Then the very next day, somewhere in the heavens, the foreign office...
16/12/2015, 17:13 OUTPOST
lament-the-terrorist-not-muslims   BY KULSOOM ZAHRA Whenever there is an act of jarring on civilians in the post 9/11 west, demagogues vehemently blame it on Muslims. In the wake...
11/12/2015, 19:33 OUTPOST
high-value-mountain-products-and-sustainable-livelihood Dr Surendra Raj Joshi The bountiful mountain areas of the Hindu Kush Himalayan (HKH) are a cornucopia of diverse, high-value products. With an...
06/12/2015, 11:09 OUTPOST
insulating-diamer-from-trouble  BY SHABBIR MIR For quite some time now, Gilgit-Baltistan’s scenic Diamer Valley has been in the spotlight, but for all the wrong reasons. It all...
10/11/2015, 17:34 OUTPOST
proposal-for-constitutional-status BY SHEHBAZ KHAN ADVOCATE(Vice Chairman Gilgit-Baltistan Bar Council) Two million people of Gilgit-Baltistan could not understand the mystery behind...
24/10/2015, 11:05 OUTPOST
mr-ghani-beware-of-the-spoilers-within BY NAVEED HUSSAIN Former Afghan president Hamid Karzai has scuttled his successor’s efforts to reconfigure his country’s troubled relationship with...
24/10/2015, 10:52 OUTPOST
hunza-s-solid-waste-management-issues-and-kado BY GOMAL AMIN KARABECK Solid waste management is a big concern for the developing countries; this is due to the lack of awareness and absence of...
09/08/2015, 23:00 OUTPOST
almost-pakistan-g-b-in-a-constitutional-limbo For the people of Gilgit-Baltistan (GB), there are two independence days every year: August 14, with the rest of Pakistan; and November 1, when they...
24/07/2015, 23:46 OUTPOST
5-islamic-philosophers-every-muslim-must-read  BY MUQTEDAR KHAN  Islamic intellectual culture suffers from a philosophy deficit. While there are a few philosophical thinkers in the...
03/07/2015, 14:37 OUTPOST
china-s-new-silk-road-what-s-in-it-for-gilgit-baltistan BY FIDA KARIM In the history of Gilgit-Baltistan, there have been some historical events and transformational incidents that have had far-reaching...
01/07/2015, 00:13 OUTPOST
challenges-for-the-new-chief-minister BY AMJAD ABBAJ SAAKA Under Gilgit-Baltistan Self Governance Order 2009, Gilgit-Baltistan [G-B] election commission conducted second general elections...
20/06/2015, 08:50 OUTPOST
challenges-for-g-b-government BY AFZAL SHIGRI  GILGIT-Baltistan (G-B) is that forgotten corner of Pakistan which only catches the media’s attention when there is a natural...
31/05/2015, 09:38 OUTPOST
g-b-elections ASIF SAKHI GILGIT: Another election is approaching fast in Gilgit-Baltistan. Various leaders have already rolled their sleeves up while their...
24/05/2015, 10:28 OUTPOST
dilemma-of-choosing-right-man-for-right-job-at-right-time ASIF SAKHI PASSU GOJAL: Another election is approaching fast in Gilgit – Baltistan [G-B]. The leaders of various kinds and forms have already rolled...
16/04/2015, 08:26 OUTPOST
the-pm-s-gilgit-baltistan-visit TARIQ RAHIM BAIG GULMIT: The recent short visit of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif to Gilgit-Baltistan (G-B) has left behind many questions in people’s...
31/03/2015, 13:30 OUTPOST
in-defence-of-trophy-hunting BY UZMA KHAN The human species has been the most detrimental to the world and is also the only species that has the most capacity and potential to help...
21/03/2015, 12:13 OUTPOST
using-public-office-for-personal-gain BY SHABBIR MIR The right to self-rule is what the people of Gilgit-Baltistan (G-B) have long demanded. Such a mode of governance was introduced in 2009...
09/03/2015, 21:46 OUTPOST
starting-point-for-g-b The young people of Gilgit-Baltistan [G-B] believe the G-B Empowerment and Self-Governance Order of 2009 should be a starting point from which the...
13/02/2015, 19:27 OUTPOST
musharraf-says-he-cultivated-taliban-in-afghanistan-in-2001 Pervez Musharraf, the former Pakistani military ruler accused of sheltering and supporting the Taliban after 2001, has called for an end to the backing...
03/02/2015, 19:11 OUTPOST
plight-of-gem-sector-in-g-b BY JALAL - UD -DIN Gilgit – Baltistan [G-B] is graciously endowed - a part from world’s highest peaks and largest glaciers - with abundance of natural...
17/01/2015, 00:15 OUTPOST
amnesty-int-l-asks-pakistan-to-end-executions-following-peshawar-attack ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s government must immediately put an end to the spate of executions in the country in the wake of the Peshawar school attack, which...
23/12/2014, 11:31 OUTPOST
who-are-we-hanging BY SARAH BELAL We have all been devastated this week by the senseless murder of at least 145 people in a school in Peshawar. We expect our government...
15/12/2014, 18:17 OUTPOST
parentage-crisis-of-my-motherland BY AMJAD HUSSAIN AZAR During the preceding month of November a debate was generated regarding legal constitutional status of Gilgit Baltistan [G-B],...
03/12/2014, 07:54 OUTPOST
g-b-s-legal-status BY NIAT WALI GILGIT: Gilgit-Baltistan (G-B), formerly known as Northern Areas of Pakistan, is a gateway to China from Pakistan and South Asian...
28/11/2014, 20:46 OUTPOST
now-what-mr-khan  BY MEHR TARAR Imran Khan seems to be at a crossroads. To move ahead, turn this way or that, make a u-turn (ah, the turns that are infamous by...
25/11/2014, 11:06 OUTPOST
iran-s-nuclear-talks-and-the-west  BY ARIFA JABEEN With the third round of Iran G6 talks approaching, nothing could really be said about the outcome. While change of regime altered...
22/11/2014, 20:41 OUTPOST
houbara-bustards-an-annual-massacre-of-national-pride BY UZAIR SHAH With the recent news of Pakistan yet again issuing hunting permits for the protected houbara bustard for the winter season, it is clear...
14/11/2014, 21:17 OUTPOST
this-is-not-gilgit-baltistan  BY AHTISHAM MIR As Muslims we all start reading Quran from our childhood, we almost finish reading whole Quran twice or thrice before we are 15...
04/10/2014, 15:46 OUTPOST
economic-management BY SAKIB SHERANI LAST week I was in Muzaffarabad, presenting a medium-term outlook for the economy at the strategic offsite meeting of one of...
30/08/2014, 15:20 OUTPOST
why-the-newspaper-feels-like-an-anachronism BY AAKAR PATEL Readership of regional language newspapers is down sharply. Years ago, the people strutting about were likely to be the Indians. This...